|
|
  |
What are you reading? |
|
|
Callidus Thorn |
Feb 29 2016, 04:08 PM
|

Councilor

Joined: 29-September 13
From: Midgard, Cyrodiil, one or two others.

|
Finished blitzing The Farseer Trilogy, and I pretty disappointed in all honesty. The first book was great; setting up a promising story, some interesting elements and characters, and established things nicely. Book two kind of gets lost partway through; develops one part of the story at the expense of another(and several characters, in the worst possible way), and goes downhill fairly quickly. Book three threw just about everything from the first book(the initial threat, and everything surrounding it) out the window in favour of following the main character on a personal and not particularly interesting tangent, before apparently remembering what it's supposed to be tying up right at the end to resolve things in a rushed and unsatisfactory manner.
I mean, you've got implacable foes with a mysterious power, betrayals and intrigue, sacrifices, interesting types of magic, and a few good characters.
But the motivation of the implacable foes, and their leader, are never dealt with directly. The betrayals and intrigue(and the bulk of the main plot, including the ending) rely on everybody involved being both spectacularly fortunate and mind-numbingly stupid, often at the same time. The sacrifices felt more like they were hammered into the plot, which warped to fit them, rather than being actually integral to the plot. And the shift of story in the third book removed most of the characters, or rendered them insignificant to the story that was actually being told. And the way it's written in the 1st person, and the circumstance behind that, remove 99% of the actual tension in the story.
I don't think I'm even going to consider reading any of her other books.
--------------------
A mind without purpose will walk in dark places
|
|
|
|
Decrepit |
Mar 4 2016, 04:29 AM
|

Master

Joined: 9-September 15
From: Mid-South USA

|
At 2019 this evening I finished Shadows Out of Hell, volume two of Andrew J. Offutt's War of the Gods on Earth. With some hesitation, I will likely continue on with the the concluding volume, The Lady of the Snowmist. QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ Feb 29 2016, 09:08 AM)  Finished blitzing The Farseer Trilogy, and I pretty disappointed in all honesty. The first book was great; setting up a promising story, some interesting elements and characters, and established things nicely. Book two kind of gets lost partway through; develops one part of the story at the expense of another(and several characters, in the worst possible way), and goes downhill fairly quickly. Book three threw just about everything from the first book(the initial threat, and everything surrounding it) out the window in favour of following the main character on a personal and not particularly interesting tangent, before apparently remembering what it's supposed to be tying up right at the end to resolve things in a rushed and unsatisfactory manner.
I mean, you've got implacable foes with a mysterious power, betrayals and intrigue, sacrifices, interesting types of magic, and a few good characters.
But the motivation of the implacable foes, and their leader, are never dealt with directly. The betrayals and intrigue(and the bulk of the main plot, including the ending) rely on everybody involved being both spectacularly fortunate and mind-numbingly stupid, often at the same time. The sacrifices felt more like they were hammered into the plot, which warped to fit them, rather than being actually integral to the plot. And the shift of story in the third book removed most of the characters, or rendered them insignificant to the story that was actually being told. And the way it's written in the 1st person, and the circumstance behind that, remove 99% of the actual tension in the story.
I don't think I'm even going to consider reading any of her other books.
I am having a reaction akin to yours with War of the Gods on Earth, though in my case volume one was nothing special. Volume two starts out in just about the worst way possible, with the main character bemoaning his lot in life aloud to his fellow shipmates for over thirty pages, in a not even thinly disguised recap of book one. Thirty-plus out of a total of only 165 pages I might add. We then continue on with your typical old-school fantasy quest . . . group of nordicesque adventurers led by our hero sail to an island inhabited by stunningly beautiful scantily clad women, to steal a sacred object as directed by their goddess. The writing is pretty simplistic, indeed primitive at time. I assumed this was the author's chosen style. or that he was not overly skilled at his craft. Then, out of the blue, well into the story, our hero dreams of or is visited by an otherworldly presence. It and he proceed to engage in deep philosophical discussions, during which the presence expounds on such things and the big-bang theory, creationism, good and evil, black & white vs shades of gray, and so on. The hero wakes. We're back to our simplistic narrative for the remainder of the novel. There are a number of erotic escapades thrown in, described in more graphic detail than is apt to be present in more recently published fantasy. I am not surprised to learn, via the author's Wiki page, that Offutt wrote a good many erotic novels under several aliases. (The eroticism doesn't bother me in the least, but I'm not prudish in such matters and would not consider it worth mentioning were it not so rare in fantasy these days. Leastwise not in those I read.)
--------------------
|
|
|
|
Decrepit |
Mar 9 2016, 09:20 PM
|

Master

Joined: 9-September 15
From: Mid-South USA

|
I have decided to reread Gene Wolfe's The Book of the New Sun, and am now a few pages into volume one, The Shadow of the Torturer. This will be its fourth reading. The first occurred 1988, the third 2002. I am also reading The World of Ice and Fire: The Untold History of Westeros and the Game of Thrones at the kitchen table during lunches and suppers. I bought the book some time last year but discovered that it is too big and heavy for me to read in bed. Since my serious pleasure reading occurs only while in bed or during meals, I at long last admitted to myself that it will never be read unless I devote mealtimes to the task. (I own a sturdy desktop book stand so that bulk and weight are not an issue.)
--------------------
|
|
|
|
Winter Wolf |
Mar 10 2016, 10:46 AM
|

Knower

Joined: 15-March 10
From: Melbourne, Australia

|
I am preparing for the end of the world. Metro 2033.But the npcs are dying in different ways to the way the game does it. It is doing my head in. The atmosphere and back stories are very cool to read. Books are always the best medium for that. You can almost taste their fear of a plague sweeping the metro.
--------------------
Games I am playing- Oblivion Remastered Resident Evil 4 Remake Assassin Creed 3 Remastered
|
|
|
|
ghastley |
Mar 16 2016, 06:47 PM
|

Councilor

Joined: 13-December 10

|
QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ Mar 16 2016, 12:35 PM)  Foundation by Isaac Asimov.
I've never gotten around to reading the Foundation books before, not sure why.
What do you consider to be the "Foundation books"? There's the initial Trilogy, written to be a complete three-part story, but he also revisited it later and wove it into the Robots series, so there's a number of later novels to bridge the two. And now I'm tempted to reread "The Endochronic Properties of Resublimated Thiotimoline" which may have been the first thing of his that I read. This post has been edited by ghastley: Mar 16 2016, 06:49 PM
--------------------
Mods for The Elder Scrolls single-player games, and I play ESO.
|
|
|
|
|
  |
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
|
|