Grits, I do agree with you and that is why the civil war is so well done as a confusing swirling sea of gray. The Imperials tried to behead Buffy under the orders of a captain who was being directly supervised by a general. Yet, when Buffy meets the grieving Elisef and listens to the logic of Sybille. . . . Similarly, Buffy sees how the city of Windhelm treats elves and assumes that, since it is the seat of Stormcloak power, such would be the policy throughout Skyrim if they were victorious. Then she hears the soul stirring speech of Ulfric inside his palace. . . . A confusion that has been wonderfully and intentionally crafted by the devs is the result.
I've also thought of Erik. He is no hero but that is not to say he could not become one. His father was a warrior and, growing up on the farm, Erick is probably strong as an ox.
