Competition Results Options

[Burnt Sierra]

Right. Before I get too this, just a couple of little comments.

I'm posting up the top five stories/authors with their placings. Just the top five. The process for determining which stories won, which made the final cut etc, laid out like this:

We read the stories, and decided upon a top ten. Each judge ( more on that in a second) then picked their favourite five, from those ten stories, and gave the following points to them.

5th place: 2 points
4th place: 4 points
3rd place: 6 points
2nd place: 8 points
1st place: 10 points

We then added the points up, and came up with the top five. This may not have been the perfect judging system, but it was the best I could come up with, and the other judges agreed with me it was the fairest.

Now..... it seems to me, that some people just didn't realise just how much reading the judges had to do. I'm not going to speak for the others, but from my perspective, I work full time, recently as much as 12 hours a day and weekends. This basically meant that I had to shelve my personal life in order to do this, which I did. However, not everybody was able to do this. Outside commitments meant that we were unable to meet our original deadline. Regrettable, but just a fact of life. Certain people's comments, and I have no intention of making this personal, meant that we felt very much under pressure to do it quickly. Out of the five judges, one judge had to drop out, and another was unable to meet the new deadline, that we'd felt we had no option but to set. With their perspective, maybe the results would have been different. Who knows? However, this is the way its panned out, and these results are final. The top five stories will all be getting pride of place in the mod (when its released) and of course, all the entries will be a part of it.

Final point. Stargate mentioned earlier he wanted feedback on his story. I'm not averse to me doing that (again, I will not speak for the other judges) but I do want you to bear one thing in mind. If everyone asks to have feedback posted, again thats a hell of a lot of work you're asking for. I'll do it, but it isn't going to be immediate. Like everything, it'll take time, so if it's something you do want, then let me know, and then be patient. Any feedback will be based upon the criteria I judged. In other words, it won't be like the feedback i post in the fanfic section. I won't be just posting up the positives, so if what I might say will offend you, you're probably better off not asking.

p.s. Now the competition is finished, I've resigned from any further part of the mod, which means Stargazey is the one true leader Any enjoyment I garnered from reading these great stories, and make no mistake, some of them were truly exceptional, has been tempered by events surrounding it. Shame, but...well, thats how it goes I guess.

The Entries:

Inziladun : The tales of Inziladun, Part 1.
Dumbkid : Jester’s Day Ball
Kell-Reevor : Blackmoth
Adanorcil : Silt Striders and fairytales
Dantrag : Ahnaressu's Travels
Minque : Serene of Cyrodiil
Lone wolf : A People Divided
Konradude : Story of Konrad
Treydog : The Story Of Trey
Override B1: The Tale of Sudhendra Vahl
MutantPenguin : Service.
Stargate_525 : The Tree.
Raithen : Some place
Jecasiruk : Trading Life
Forrest_Roberts : Rain
G1adiat0r : The Journey to the Barrier
Kashaaz : New Dawn
The Wolf : Hunter or the Hunted?
Wurlon : The Coyoteman
Sir Radont : Neron
Rumpleteasza : The King And I
Mushroom-hunter-d : A Second Spring



The Top Ten:

Dumbkid : Jester’s Day Ball
Dantrag : Ahnaressu's Travels
Minque : Serene of Cyrodiil
Konradude : Story of Konrad
Treydog : The Story Of Trey
Override B1: The Tale of Sudhendra Vahl
Wurlon : The Coyoteman
Sir Radont : Neron
Rumpleteasza : The King And I
Mushroom-hunter-d : A Second Spring



The Top Five:

5th place) Minque : Serene of Cyrodiil – 8 points
4th place) Rumpleteasza : The King And I– 14 points
3rd place) Mushroom-hunter-d : A Second Spring – 18 points
2nd place) Treydog : The Story Of Trey – 20 points
1st place) Override B1 : The Tale of Sudhendra Vahl – 26 points



So there we have it.

[minque]

First I want to thank all the judges for the hard work and all the effort you have put into this.I understand that all of you have spent a great deal of your free time in just reading all the entries. I just hope you think it was worth it!

So a big warm HUG to all of you!!!

Then I must admit I´m utterly flattered of being mentioned alongside with four really professional writers.!....And that despite me being an outlander, not having english as my first language.

OverrideB1 is a well worthy winner, as he is the Master of Words....

I have read all the stories of Override, treydog, Rumpleteasza and mushroom-hunter, and I have but one comment on those stories: Awesome and professional!

So I thank you again and I am very happy to be one of the top 5 here

-minque

[Wurlon]

Then I must admit I´m utterly flattered of being mentioned alongside with four really professional writers.!....And that despite me being an outlander, not having english as my first language.
-minque

There is no need for language when meaning is present.


double post! whoops

This post has been edited by Wurlon: Feb 21 2006, 04:17 AM